Legal Theories

509 claims, defenses, counterclaims, and affirmative defenses

Data license: Public court records

23 rows where filing_id = 43 and role = "affirmative_defense"

This data as json, CSV (advanced)

theory_id ▼ filing_id theory party role basis
298 43 43 Statute of Limitations Kassab affirmative_defense Pohl's claims accrued before the limitations period
299 43 43 Justification Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #2
300 43 43 Estoppel Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #3
301 43 43 Waiver Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #4
302 43 43 Ratification Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #5
303 43 43 Release Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #6
304 43 43 Unclean Hands Kassab affirmative_defense Pohl's alleged barratry constitutes unclean hands barring equitable relief
305 43 43 Contribution Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #8
306 43 43 Failure to Mitigate Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #9
307 43 43 Lack of Standing Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #10
308 43 43 Accord and Satisfaction Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #11
309 43 43 Assumption of the Risk Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #12
310 43 43 Illegality/Criminal Acts (Unlawful Acts Doctrine) Kassab affirmative_defense Pohl's claims are predicated on property obtained through illegal barratry, a third-degree felony under Tex. Penal Code § 38.12
311 43 43 First Amendment Kassab affirmative_defense Barratry lawsuits and grievances communicated matters of public concern
312 43 43 Attorney Immunity Kassab affirmative_defense Kassab's actions were within scope of attorney duties representing barratry victims
313 43 43 Judicial Immunity Kassab affirmative_defense Actions taken in connection with judicial proceedings
314 43 43 Rule 17.09 Immunity Kassab affirmative_defense Immunity for filing grievances and participating in attorney disciplinary system under Texas Rules of Disciplinary Procedure
315 43 43 In Pari Delicto Kassab affirmative_defense Pohl bears equal or greater blame for the situation
316 43 43 Res Judicata Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #19
317 43 43 Defect of Parties Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #20
318 43 43 Abandonment Kassab affirmative_defense Pohl abandoned the alleged documents with a convicted felon and never requested their return
319 43 43 Subject of a Valid Contract Kassab affirmative_defense Listed as affirmative defense #22
320 43 43 TUTSA Preemption Kassab affirmative_defense TUTSA preempts Pohl's other claims per Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 134A.007(a)

Advanced export

JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object

CSV options: 

CREATE TABLE legal_theories (
    theory_id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
    filing_id INTEGER REFERENCES filings(filing_id),
    theory TEXT,
    party TEXT,
    role TEXT,
    basis TEXT
);