Legal Theories
Data license: Public court records
6 rows where filing_id = 55, party = "Pohl" and role = "opposition"
This data as json, CSV (advanced)
| theory_id ▼ | filing_id | theory | party | role | basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 389 | 55 55 | Motion to reconsider under 281st Court Procedure I(I) | Pohl | opposition | The Amended Motion is substantively a motion to reconsider because it seeks the same relief with the same arguments as the denied MSJs; such motions must be heard by submission only under court procedures. |
| 390 | 55 55 | No-evidence summary judgment — futility of repeated challenges after evidence showing | Pohl | opposition | Once a party has presented sufficient evidence to defeat a no-evidence motion, further no-evidence challenges on the same elements are futile. Pohl's prior 30+ exhibits addressed every element. |
| 391 | 55 55 | Preemption of unlawful acts doctrine by proportionate responsibility statute (Dugger v. Arredondo) | Pohl | opposition | The Texas Supreme Court explicitly found the common law unlawful acts doctrine is 'no longer a viable defense,' preempted by the proportionate responsibility statute. |
| 392 | 55 55 | Trade secret protection — reasonable measures to maintain secrecy (disputed facts) | Pohl | opposition | Pohl testified about reasonable steps taken. Same witnesses Kassab relies on also testified Pohl limited access and ensured confidentiality. Disputed material facts preclude summary judgment. |
| 393 | 55 55 | Ownership of trade secrets — disputed facts preclude summary judgment | Pohl | opposition | Walker, Ladner, and Seymour gave conflicting testimony on whether information belonged to them or Pohl. Disputed material facts preclude summary judgment. |
| 394 | 55 55 | Unlawful acts doctrine inapplicable when claims don't require reliance on illegal acts | Pohl | opposition | When the illegal conduct arises in a defense and not in the plaintiff's case, the unlawful acts rule will not bar a plaintiff's claims (Carcamo-Lopez). Pohl's claims don't require reference to any illegal act. |
Advanced export
JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object
CREATE TABLE legal_theories (
theory_id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
filing_id INTEGER REFERENCES filings(filing_id),
theory TEXT,
party TEXT,
role TEXT,
basis TEXT
);