Key Assertions
Data license: Public court records
14 rows where filing_id = 28
This data as json, CSV (advanced)
| assertion_id ▼ | filing_id | assertion |
|---|---|---|
| 484 | 28 28 | None of the eight alleged RTPs caused or contributed to the harms underlying Pohl's conversion and TUTSA claims |
| 485 | 28 28 | Texas has not adopted a 'butterfly effect' theory of proportionate responsibility |
| 486 | 28 28 | The statute applies only to tort claims and requires responsibility be determined as to each cause of action asserted |
| 487 | 28 28 | Responsibility for 'harm' (injury) is distinct from responsibility for 'damages' |
| 488 | 28 28 | The conversion harm is Defendants' 'unlawful taking' of Pohl's property — not acts by non-party runners |
| 489 | 28 28 | Each wrongful possession of converted property is a separate conversion — Walker/Seymour/Ladner's possession is distinct from Defendants' possession |
| 490 | 28 28 | The TUTSA harm is Defendants' unauthorized 'use' of Pohl's trade secrets — 'use' means commercial use by which the offending party seeks to profit |
| 491 | 28 28 | Multiple TUTSA harms: (1) Favre/Precision/Nicholson's sale of trade secrets to Kassab/Montague, (2) Kassab/Montague's use of stolen secrets to bring lawsuits against Pohl |
| 492 | 28 28 | Shepherd's alleged failure to prevent third-party tortious conduct at most 'furnished a condition that made the injury possible' — not proximate cause |
| 493 | 28 28 | Kassab's theory that Shepherd failed to protect Pohl from Kassab's tortious conduct is 'as ridiculous as it sounds' |
| 494 | 28 28 | Kassab makes no particularized allegations concerning Dona Pohl at all |
| 495 | 28 28 | For Dona, Jaimes, Talley, and Santana, Kassab merely stated they could have breached a duty 'if' they 'had an agreement and/or duty to safeguard any property' — without ever alleging such an agreement or duty existed |
| 496 | 28 28 | Kassab's disclosure responses did not name Shepherd as a potential RTP and provided no addresses or phone numbers for any alleged RTP |
| 497 | 28 28 | Pohl's conversion and TUTSA claims are subject to two- and three-year statutes of limitations respectively, which have run since the 2018 filing |
Advanced export
JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object
CREATE TABLE key_assertions (
assertion_id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
filing_id INTEGER REFERENCES filings(filing_id),
assertion TEXT
);