Key Assertions
Data license: Public court records
13 rows where filing_id = 38
This data as json, CSV (advanced)
| assertion_id ▼ | filing_id | assertion |
|---|---|---|
| 677 | 38 38 | Kassab facilitated seven separate grievances and four lawsuits against Pohl, all based on barratry theory |
| 678 | 38 38 | Every grievance failed, often with findings that conduct did not constitute professional misconduct |
| 679 | 38 38 | Two lawsuits resulted in final judgments on the merits in favor of Pohl |
| 680 | 38 38 | In the third lawsuit, Pohl settled for less than the cost of defense — not the 'substantial sum of money' alleged by Kassab |
| 681 | 38 38 | The Cheatham appellate reversal was on limitations and extraterritoriality grounds, not because barratry was found |
| 682 | 38 38 | The Cheatham case involves only two sets of wrongful-death claimants out of 10,000+ of Pohl's clients whose information defendants misappropriated |
| 683 | 38 38 | The outcome of the Cheatham case is not relevant to Pohl's claims; its relevance is only that defense fees are a component of actual damages |
| 684 | 38 38 | Kassab and David Kassab argued in Beatty v. Knighton that the unlawful acts doctrine was 'no longer good law' |
| 685 | 38 38 | The unlawful acts doctrine was preempted by Texas's proportionate responsibility statute (Dugger v. Arredondo) |
| 686 | 38 38 | Even if the unlawful acts doctrine applied, Pohl's alleged barratry was not a proximate cause of the injuries from defendants' conversion and misappropriation |
| 687 | 38 38 | Kassab's 'unclean hands' defense is inapplicable because it applies only to equitable relief and requires injury to the person raising the defense (In re Nolle) |
| 688 | 38 38 | Kassab does not explain how the outcome of Cheatham could have preclusive effect in this lawsuit involving different parties |
| 689 | 38 38 | Kassab does not explain what further factual development in Cheatham is necessary or impactful to issues in this case |
Advanced export
JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object
CREATE TABLE key_assertions (
assertion_id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
filing_id INTEGER REFERENCES filings(filing_id),
assertion TEXT
);