legal_theories: 417

509 claims, defenses, counterclaims, and affirmative defenses

Data license: Public court records

This data as json

theory_id	filing_id	theory	party	role	basis
417	59	Tort of another doctrine not viable in Texas; even if viable, requires wholly innocent plaintiff	Kassab	defense	Never embraced by Texas Supreme Court; flatly rejected by Fourteenth Court of Appeals; multiple intermediate courts have refused to adopt it; jury found in Q3 that Pohl's wrongful conduct contributed to injury, negating wholly innocent requirement