Key Assertions
Data license: Public court records
16 rows where filing_id = 55
This data as json, CSV (advanced)
| assertion_id ▼ | filing_id | assertion |
|---|---|---|
| 931 | 55 55 | The Amended Motion does not specify what prior motions it purports to amend |
| 932 | 55 55 | Kassab does not explain why the prior rulings denying summary judgment were wrong |
| 933 | 55 55 | The vast majority of the Amended Motion is directly copied and pasted from Kassab's prior denied MSJs |
| 934 | 55 55 | Under 281st Court Procedure I(I), all motions to reconsider are heard by submission only |
| 935 | 55 55 | Kassab filed his January 4, 2023 Motion to Reconsider with the 189th District Court despite the case having been transferred |
| 936 | 55 55 | The Amended Motion contains only 5 new exhibits (out of 65 total) and 2 new out-of-state cases |
| 937 | 55 55 | Once Pohl provided sufficient evidence on each element in prior briefing (30+ exhibits), further no-evidence challenges on the same elements are futile |
| 938 | 55 55 | Kassab's sole new no-evidence argument — that Pohl must prove he is 'wholly innocent in the illegal obtainment of any client' — is not an element of any of Pohl's claims, unsupported by authority |
| 939 | 55 55 | Kassab selectively cites testimony that is contradicted by the same witnesses in the same depositions |
| 940 | 55 55 | Walker, Ladner, and Seymour testified both that information was theirs AND that it was Pohl's — creating disputed material facts |
| 941 | 55 55 | Mary Arnold testified she understood Pohl owned the relevant information and it was not to be shared or discussed around third parties |
| 942 | 55 55 | Pohl testified about reasonable steps to protect client information, confidential information, and trade secrets |
| 943 | 55 55 | Dugger v. Arredondo explicitly found the common law unlawful acts doctrine is 'no longer a viable defense' |
| 944 | 55 55 | Even if not preempted, Pohl does not need to rely on any illegal act to establish his claims — the illegal conduct arises in Kassab's defense, not Pohl's case |
| 945 | 55 55 | Alderson dealt with a False Claims Act / tax characterization issue — factually inapposite to customer list trade secret protection |
| 946 | 55 55 | No Texas case has adopted the Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition § 40 privilege to disclose trade secrets cited in Merckle GmbH |
Advanced export
JSON shape: default, array, newline-delimited, object
CREATE TABLE key_assertions (
assertion_id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
filing_id INTEGER REFERENCES filings(filing_id),
assertion TEXT
);